Redesign vs. Optimization : Insights from a comprehensive website audit.
Audit
Our services
When a website's performance stagnates or declines, it is tempting to completely redesign it. However, a redesign is not always the best solution. In many cases, a series of targeted optimizations is enough to significantly improve results. How can you decide ? The answer lies in a comprehensive website audit that can accurately diagnose your site's strengths and weaknesses.
A website audit is not a formality. It is a critical step in digital strategy. It provides a comprehensive, factual, and actionable overview of the site's status, enabling informed decisions to be made.
Redesign is costly, time-consuming, and risky. It is only necessary when the foundations are no longer viable. The decision between redesign and optimization is a strategic one.
Your site is based on an unmaintained CMS, outdated architecture, or code that is impossible to upgrade. You can no longer guarantee its security or integrate modern features. If the tree structure no longer allows you to add pages or if the navigation is confusing, a redesign is the only viable solution to avoid technical debt.
The site is not very intuitive, difficult to navigate, not mobile-friendly, or visually outdated. Bounce rates are structurally high. Here, the design and usability need to be completely rethought.
Your company has evolved (new target audience, new products, change in positioning), but your website no longer reflects this reality. A redesign is an opportunity to align your digital storefront with your new brand objectives.
A redesign is not always the best solution. It is costly, time-consuming, and sometimes unnecessary. A well-conducted website audit can help you avoid this.
404 errors, slow loading times, uncompressed images : these are common problems that can be fixed without a complete overhaul. These Core Web Vitals issues (LCP, CLS) can often be resolved through targeted optimization.
Poorly written title tags, a lack of internal linking, content that needs rewriting : these are all elements that can be corrected through on-site SEO optimization, without affecting the structure of the site. An SEO audit reveals these quick wins.
Are your CTAs not standing out ? Are your key pages poorly laid out ? A partial UX redesign (without touching the CMS or structure) can make your site more readable and target obstacles to conversion.
Does your website already have good positioning, regular traffic, and a modern design ? Focus on conversion analysis and a continuous improvement plan to increase efficiency.
A good audit is more than just a list of problems. It provides a clear, prioritized, action-oriented vision.
Objective : Identify issues that slow down loading and security. We use benchmark tools such as Google PageSpeed Insights and Lighthouse to evaluate Core Web Vitals and web performance.
Objective : to evaluate the site's visibility on Google. Criteria analyzed : indexing, markup (title, Hn, meta), content, internal linking. Tools such as Screaming Frog and Search Console are essential for performing a technical SEO audit.
Objective : to understand user behavior. Methods : analysis of heatmaps (Hotjar), user journeys, bounce rates, user tests. The UX audit focuses on the clarity of the value proposition and mobile usability.
Objective : analyze the performance of key pages. Indicators : click-through rate, form completion, purchase funnels. It identifies obstacles that reduce ROI.
Each diagnosis must result in concrete, prioritized recommendations, with an estimate of potential gains and a clear choice between redesign and optimization.
A website audit becomes a management tool as soon as the strategic summary is complete. You can then :
Analysis should not be static : it should drive progress. Audits enable better investment decisions and the development of a coherent digital strategy.
Any questions ? Please don't hesitate to contact us, we would be happy to help.
The cost depends on the size of the site and the depth of the analysis. A comprehensive website audit typically takes between 5 and 15 business days to analyze and draft strategic recommendations.
Yes. Even a new website can encounter invisible problems (poorly configured SEO, technical errors, poor UX). An audit allows you to optimize from the outset and ensure alignment with Google's requirements.
The timeframe varies. Simple technical fixes can unlock traffic within a few weeks. UX and content optimizations typically take 3 to 6 months to show consolidated results.
